View Full Version : Which Marvel cartoon was the best???
I.R Joey
07-01-2001, 02:28 AM
Okay here we go. I'm going to go with the old X-men series. Sure it didn't have very solid animation, but it just left an impression on me. Now whenever I think of those charecters I imagine those voices (or maybe it's just to much Capcom stuff) speaking. They're potrayal of Magneto was awesome as well. The episode Enter Magneto was awesome.
BTW Again I apologize to the Hulk fans. I'd include all the cartoons if I could. I would have also included the Surfer cartoon (Lady Chaos!?!?! What's wrong Fox don't think kids can deal with the concept of death?.)
James Harvey
07-01-2001, 02:32 AM
X-Men. The animation may have been mostly sloppy (although there were some great animetd episode slike OUT OF THE PAST) but the series was the best thing Marvel churned out, animated wise.
Inque
07-01-2001, 02:39 AM
FANTASTIC FOUR!!!
They're one of the best Marvel comic series out there!!
Spider-man comes in second because it has hydro-man and some other cool villians.
mxyzptlk
07-01-2001, 11:19 AM
x-men
James Harvey
07-01-2001, 12:36 PM
I will givea nod to the second season of the MARVEL ACTION HOUR for improving a ten fold over the horrible first season episodes. There are some second season FF and Iron Man episodes that rocked. Also, the very dark first season on UPN's INCREDIBLE HULK was also very, very cool.
I.R Joey
07-01-2001, 03:56 PM
Yeah props to whoever did the 2nd season of Iron man especially. Considering what they had to work with as far as continuity from the 1st season.
mxyzptlk
07-01-2001, 05:47 PM
i never saw but like one episode of iron man
joker
07-02-2001, 01:58 PM
you left out the hulk cartoon show! i loved this show. it was great. it just got put on a crappy station(upn) and a really crappy time (10:30 sunday mourning) righ when im at church gaa. i hade to tape it each time and i forgot about it some of the time. but very good show. i wish it wouldve lasted more that one season
Mr. Eye
07-02-2001, 03:10 PM
Spidey by far.
Mr. Eye
Kylewayne
07-03-2001, 03:13 PM
X-MEN
mxyzptlk
07-03-2001, 04:22 PM
Originally posted by Mr. Eye
Spidey by far.
Mr. Eye
you are crazy senior x men is better.
Nightwing
07-03-2001, 06:48 PM
Spiderman is my pick too, by far. I loved X-Men too though. Heck, sure the first season was horribly animated, but why count that against the show when the second season was gorgeous!
Anyway, back to Spidey. I loved it. It was my first exposure to Spiderman, so that shows that since it made me love and understand the characters as much as it would a comic fan, they must have done something right.
The only problems I think the series had was after a few seasons they started recycling animation in more easy to see areas (not just the swinging past buildings thing) and at the same time spreading far far away from the comic's storylines.
A few times I can see why they did it. Like dodging Gwen Stacey for example. But the episodes with Electro, though really great, were so far off story wize. It was true to most of the characters though, like Spidey and Cap.
James Harvey
07-03-2001, 08:09 PM
HULK was awesome. The first season ruled. The 3 part finale was great. The 2nd season was merely okay becuase they brightened and chucked in SHE-HULK who was so annoying. X-MEN, I thoguth got great in season three, with the Phoneix stuff. Spidey...well...it was good.
Mr. Eye
07-03-2001, 10:39 PM
Let me repeat myself, Spider-Man by FAR :)
First off, the animation was 20 times better. Second of all, I like it when my cartoons don't have too much cheesy dialogue. Plus I think Spidey is the more superior character over any given X-Men.
Mr. Eye
DerekPowers
07-04-2001, 02:42 PM
i'd say x-men. that show had some great stories and eps, and was overall damn good. spiderman was okay, but got really crappy with all that madam web stuff, and ff was pretty good. and mr. eye, what do you mean you like your cartoons without pointless dialogue?! spiderman was full of that, that was the most annoying part about the show, how a villian would be asked a simple question and then just go on and on and on, revealing everything in their lives......that was annoying.
James
07-04-2001, 04:13 PM
Spider-Man.
X-Men was incrediably faithful - and enjoyable, but always felt a little neutered. Wolverine was reduced to showing his claws 20 times and episodes but unable to do anything with them (unless there was a metal door requiring an opening) and the dark elements of the comic never really made their way across to the TV version. I think the set X-Men team gave it distance from the ever changing comic version.
Still a worthy attempt and a highly enjoyable show.
Spider-Man, IMO, captured the essence of the comic. Peter's dialogue was perfect, his personal life was captured perfectly and Spider-Man was the hero he should be.
Admittedly it's job was easier as the Spidey comics aren't half as dark and complicated as the X-Men - but it produced the stuff.
My only complaint would be that it's 'Sagas' were a little too long..
My favourite Marvel cartoons aren't listed here. The 80's Incredible Hulk cartoon (loved the score!! - reprised in Dungeons and Dragons) and Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends (wasn't AT ALL faithful but was a lot of fun!!). Have fond memories of both those cartoons....
Mr. Eye
07-04-2001, 04:20 PM
Hey there. I said cheesy dialogue, not pointless. I thought it was too stilted in X-Men. Maybe it was the acting, I don't know. Plus u know how characters always talk to themselves? Spider-Man is a loner, he's supposed to talk to himself. I didn't like it how everybody talked to themselves in X-Men.
Mr. Eye
Originally posted by DerekPowers
i'd say x-men. that show had some great stories and eps, and was overall damn good. spiderman was okay, but got really crappy with all that madam web stuff, and ff was pretty good. and mr. eye, what do you mean you like your cartoons without pointless dialogue?! spiderman was full of that, that was the most annoying part about the show, how a villian would be asked a simple question and then just go on and on and on, revealing everything in their lives......that was annoying.
Jedi Knight
07-04-2001, 05:48 PM
Spiderman takes my vote. That show just got me so involved. I was addicted to it, and I just couldn't get enough.
X-Men was good too, but it really seemed to trail off after the Phoenix Saga. The episodes were just of lower quality overall. Spiderman stayed strong (at least for me) all the way through.
DR. BELCH
07-04-2001, 06:06 PM
--with Jed on this one. Spiderman had a lot of character development....I actually cried when the Mary Jane clone "died" in Peter's arms, and I liked seeing how young Osborne's multiple personality disorder was played out ...plus The Kingpin is much more menacing when he hides behind a normal name like Wilson Fisk and, like Lex Luthor, uses the cover of philanthropy (in the original stories everybody knew he was a crime boss and s.o.b.; that had to hurt his effectiveness). Doctor Doom was handled even better here than in the FF series; nice to see how his anger and depravity cooled when he somehow managed to find a cure for his horrible facial scars. X-Men is a close second, with Fantastic Four and Silver Surfer tied for third....
Firefly
07-04-2001, 08:54 PM
Spider-Man:)
I.R Joey
07-04-2001, 10:52 PM
Dead heat between Spidey and X-men.
And did noobody love Iron Man's second season like me and DG.
James Harvey
07-05-2001, 01:31 AM
The ARMOR WARS in the 2nd season of IRON MAN was a blast. Plus, the AVENGERS cameos in the 2nd season were so much better than anything that came out of that flat and terrible AVENGERS series, which is by far the worst thing churned out. Ever. I just liked X-MEN better for some reason. SANCTUARY being my favorite X-MEN episodes, which I'm glad are on DVD. SPIDER-MAN was good, but I didn't like how they constantly reused the same webslinging clips and rushed the dialogue. The stock footage sometimes did mesh at all. BTW - Rumor has it UNIVERSAL will be releasing SPIDER-MAN DVDs. They are currently releasing the animated X-MEN DVDs.
I have all these serie son tape 9SPIDER-MAN, X-MEN, IRONA MAN, FF, SILVER SURFER, HULK, not AVENGERS) and I never tire of watching them. I'll pop a tape in from time to time. Can't wait for the eventual DVD release...
Calhoun07
07-05-2001, 12:24 PM
These are confirmed to be coming out on DVD?
James Harvey
07-05-2001, 12:51 PM
The mid-90s Spider-Man series will be release on DVD. It's being pursued to tie into the upcoming movie. The studio that is releasing it is not 100%, but there's a strong chance it will be UNIVERSAL.
Mr. Eye
07-05-2001, 12:58 PM
But are we going to get the whole series, or just 2 DVD's in total with like 4 episodes each?
Mr. Eye
Originally posted by DickGrayson
The mid-90s Spider-Man series will be release on DVD. It's being pursued to tie into the upcoming movie. The studio that is releasing it is not 100%, but there's a strong chance it will be UNIVERSAL.
I.R Joey
07-05-2001, 09:00 PM
No not the Avengers, good grief.
"Wind's of destiny change so that such a stupid cartoon would never be made again."
Vision was cool in that show though.
James Harvey
07-05-2001, 10:57 PM
If UNIVERSAL gets the liscense, they plan to the same as they are doing with the X-MEN series which is releasing random episodes onto DVD until they're all eventually out there. Or until things get unprofitable then they'll just stop. But the animated X-MEN DVDs have been huge hits, so UNIVERSAL wil likely be releasing them for time to come. Plus, Marvel plans to start putting comic trailers on the DVDs, to entice new readers.
The studio isn't confirmed yet, but that's UNIVERSAL's plan. Just release episodes.
Calhoun07
07-05-2001, 11:14 PM
That sux. Why can't they put them out in order?
icecold
07-06-2001, 12:31 AM
For me it's a tie between Spidey and X-Men. No offense to those who liked them but I thought Iron Man and to an extent Incredible Hulk sucked.
oranthal
07-06-2001, 09:33 PM
i certainly liked the 2nd season of "iron man" and "fantastic four." the quality of the animation the stories increased many times over. where i live, these shows were showed on sunday which probably explains why these shows are not known by a lot of people. if they were on saturday mornings, they would definitely get more run.
Originally posted by I.R Joey
Dead heat between Spidey and X-men.
And did noobody love Iron Man's second season like me and DG.
vBulletin® v3.8.2, Copyright ©2000-2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.