Winx Club vs Totally Spies

[Sammie]

Witch do you like the best Winx Club or Totally Spies? I like Totally Spies better. I hate Winx Club.

[Silverstar]

What, if I may ask, is the point of this thread?

For one thing, Winx Club hasn't aired on CN in some time, so this hardly qualifies as a CN poll.

For another, what in the blue shell do Totally Spies and Winx Club actually have in common that anyone can make an accurate comparison between them? The 2 shows are nothing alike. It's like comparing steak tartar to a raspberry sundae.

Finally, how can we expect any unbiased opinion from you, when you've already stated that you flat-out hate Winx Club and you've already made it clear that you're a Totally Spies super-fan. So other than declaring adoration for Totally Spies and using that as a flimsy excuse to trash Winx Club (a show which is nothing like Totally Spies in any way), I fail to see what you hope to generate with this poll.

[Sammie]

What, if I may ask, is the point of this thread?

For one thing, Winx Club hasn't aired on CN in some time, so this hardly qualifies as a CN poll.

For another, what in the blue shell do Totally Spies and Winx Club actually have in common that anyone can make an accurate comparison between them? The 2 shows are nothing alike. It's like comparing steak tartar to a raspberry sundae.

Finally, how can we expect any unbiased opinion from you, when you've already stated that you flat-out hate Winx Club and you've already made it clear that you're a Totally Spies super-fan. So other than declaring adoration for Totally Spies and using that as a flimsy excuse to trash Winx Club (a show which is nothing like Totally Spies in any way), I fail to see what you hope to generate with this poll.

Do you enjoy watching Totally Spies or winx club more why does the shows have to be alike to answer that? And I just wanted to make a thread since I only mad like one. I did not make it to trash winx My sister wacthes it as you can see it's winning anyway.

[Silverstar]

But Winx Club doesn't even air on Cartoon Network, and the 2 shows aren't anything alike. That would be like if I created a poll asking which show do people prefer: Chowder or Heroes? The latter doesn't even air on CN and is a completely different show with a completely different tone and style from the former. So trying to compare the 2 makes no sense.

Whichever show you happen to prefer is your own choice, but it's silly to try and tout the superiority of one show over another when the 2 shows in question have next to nothing in common in the first place. It's simply not a fair or accurate comparison.

[John Dorian]

How about..."Winx Club vs. W.I.T.C.H.? They're similar.

[Sammie]

How about..."Winx Club vs. W.I.T.C.H.? They're similar.

:cool:

[Silverstar]

How about..."Winx Club vs. W.I.T.C.H.? They're similar.

John has a point: while neither show airs on CN, Winx Club has more in common with W.I.T.C.H. than it does with Totally Spies.

But alas, Winx VS W.I.T.C.H. is another debate I refuse to take sides on, for the simple fact that it's possible to Like. Them. Both.

Both shows have their own strengths and weaknesses, so I can't-and won't-pick a favorite amongst them. It would be nice if the debaters would stop trying to put one show over the other and learn to appreciate the merits of each.

[Sammie]

John has a point: while neither show airs on CN, Winx Club has more in common with W.I.T.C.H. than it does with Totally Spies.

But alas, Winx VS W.I.T.C.H. is another debate I refuse to take sides on, for the simple fact that it's possible to Like. Them. Both.

Both shows have their own strengths and weaknesses, so I can't-and won't-pick a favorite amongst them. It would be nice if the debaters would stop trying to put one show over the other and learn to appreciate the merits of each.

Okay point taken.

[Jave]

I'm going to lock this topic because it really doesn't belong here.

Sammie, there's nothing that doesn't allow "Vs." threads, but please make sure the options pertain to a specific board. If you want to restart this specific topic, try the General Animation Forum. Also, it's better that you elaborate better on why you choose on over the other.

Silverstar, if you feel a topic doesn't fit the boards please report it instead of taking matters into your own hands. If people want to debate which show is better, there nothing wrong with it. I suggest you follow your own advice, "If you don't like it, don't watch it." That can apply to forum topics as well.

Closed