Cul-de-sac kids vs Endsville Elementry class

[zoombie]

Which supporting kids characters do you think are better overal? Being funny characters, likeability, and just interesting, etc.

The Cul-de-sac kids from Ed, Edd, n Eddy, or Billy and Mandy's classmates. (I referred to them as Endville Elementory class, even though the name of the school is unknown, the Billy and Mandy crew don't have an offical name)

There are a lot of simularities between characters, and also complete opposites.

A big difference are the Eds classmates are series regulars, while Billy and Mandy's classmates are recuring characters except for Irwin who has appeared in a majority of the episodes since season 2.

[yoshirider13]

I think The Ed crew is way funnier. Its just got a good set of characters with their own personalities. I especially like Ed and Johnny because they have the most funny episodes (except Johnny's superhero one -_-)

[Dr.Pepper]

Yeah I like the kids on Ed Edd n Eddy better. I just know them better and they play a better role on the show.

[DarthGonzo]

Oh definitely the cast of Ed, Edd and Eddy. While I like Irwin and Puddin', I'm not a fan of Sperg and I really dislike Mindy. And...who else is there?

[zoombie]

I think The Ed crew is way funnier. Its just got a good set of characters with their own personalities. I especially like Ed and Johnny because they have the most funny episodes (except Johnny's superhero one -_-)

Okay but lets try to factor the Eds, Billy and Mandy out of this. Talk about the other characters.

I think the Cul - de - sac have an advantage in being more episodes, the characters get more chances to develop, and show different sides to their personalites. And more multy dimental characters, instead of just being the jock, bully, nerd, popular girl, nerd, etc. Besides the Eds and the Kanker sisters, they are only characters on the show.

While the Billy and Mandy classmates with the exception of Irwin (who I think is hillarous), play a smaller role, and don't get that chance. Though there are rare occassions in which they grow a little bit or show a different side like the episodes "Wishbone" and "Billy And Mandy Moon The Moon."

Anyone think Jimmy and Puddin are very similar like I do? Or that Nazz and Mindy while they play the same roles, they are complete opposites? They have the same priverlerage, but treat them in different ways. They would be perfect bizzaro world mates.

Edit: Who else is there? To answer that person's question there is Junior (Billy's cousin), the beatneck kid, and Piff (the kid Mandy breifly had a crush on), and the boys from the Secret Snake Club (they only appeared in two episodes, I don't know if they count)

PS: Who doesn't dislike Mindy? I love it when bad stuff happens to her, like being tied to a rocket to the moon in "Wishbone" or being vanished to a black hole in "Secret Decoder Ring", or Pandora's box turning her face ugly.

[Kury Wagner]

Ed, Edd, n Eddy's supporting cast has a lot more personality and they rely on them a lot more than Billy, Mandy, and Grim do on a regular basis.

[Ishtar]

The Cul-de-sac kids of Ed,Ed N Eddy are much better than the Endsville kids of Billy and Mandy.

[Dark Soul]

Ed, Edd, and Eddy hands down have a better supporting cast. They all contribute a great part to the show and can steal the spotlight at anytime.

[Darklordavaitor]

I'd rather have a safe and interesting day in the Cul-De-Sac than get attacked by all the creatures of the Underworld in Endsville. Think about it.

[zoombie]

I agree with you guys, Cul-de-sac gang are better.

But I have to admit, Irwin has grown on me, he was one of the things that made Big Boogie Adventure a great movie.

[Draft]

A tough one goes to Cul-De-Sac. While Sperg, Pud'n, Irwin, and Nergal Jr. all have humorous appearances in the series, I think Rolf, Jonny 2x4, and Plank have much better appearances..

[Kury Wagner]

I agree with you guys, Cul-de-sac gang are better.

But I have to admit, Irwin has grown on me, he was one of the things that made Big Boogie Adventure a great movie.But Irwin has a bigger part than, say, Sperg, though. =\

[zoombie]

But Irwin has a bigger part than, say, Sperg, though. =\

I know I said that from the beginning. he has a larger role than the other kid supporting characters. And overal only Billy's parents have an equal important supporting role. Irwin is somewhere between Billy, Mandy, Grim, and the recuring characters. Since season 2 or 3 when he was promoted from a recuring character to a semi regular character, while he is not in every episode, he is in the majority of them.

In terms of importance or number of appearance, he is more like the Cul-de-sac gang, than the other Billy and Mandy classmate pears.

[kewlmyc]

Cul-de-sac kids FTW!

Why? One word: Rolf.

[DarthGonzo]

Cul-de-sac kids FTW!

Why? One word: Rolf.

And in three words: Jonny and Plank

[Deadman]

i think the cul de sac kids are funnier.

[oofadoofa]

I vote for the Peach Creek gang. There's more mysteries about them. Is Plank alive? Where is Rolf from? ect.
The Endsville kids, (minus Irwin) are mostly one-note and don't get much screen time.

[bigddan11]

#1- It's Elementary, not Elementory.

#2- I hate both shows, but I can tolerate Billy & Mandy a little more than Ed, Edd, an Eddy since Mandy is not as stupid as the Ed's and tends to have a personality similiar to mine.

[.bg]

The school from Cow and Chicken wins.