PDA

View Full Version : Dalek’s thoughts on Doctor Who: R1 DVD WAVE 15.


Lord Dalek
11-09-2005, 02:15 AM
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2398-0.jpg



Story: *** ½ Video: **** Sound: **** Extras: **** Overall: ****

What a surprise! For once UNIT is facing a benevolent alien menace! The Axons claim to be the last survivors of a race of biological engineers. In return for minerals, they will give humans Axonite, a rock like material impervious to radiation. The Doctor is suspicious of the British Government’s plan for this new material and the presence of his nemesis The Master (Roger Delgado), still on the run after the Stangmore Prison riots, only complicates things. Unsurprisingly though, Axos isn’t really benevolent after all and Axonite has some nasty properties.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2398-2.jpg



Claws of Axos is the first story of the legendary season 8 (aka the Master Season) to make it onto shiny disc. While it would have been nicer to have either Terror of the Autons or The Daemons, this one’s still pretty good. Pertwee’s always at his best when dueling it out with Delgado and Axos has got a lot of that. Some very inventive sets and effects are also on display here.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2398-3.jpg

Now this is a very important release as it marks the debut of the DWRT’s new toy, Reverse Standards Conversion. Episodes two and three were originally shot on PAL video. Unfortunately those tapes were later wiped (along with almost all of Season 7, and most of Season 9). However before said wiping occurred, conversions to NTSC for the North American market were made. These became the broadcast masters when recovered from TV Ontario in the late 70’s. Regrettably, like all NTSC’d material, these suffer from visible line structure, some heavy grain, phasing errors in shot transitions, and annoying motion artifacts. The latter two have now completely disappeared thanks to the RSC process. It still doesn’t look as good as PAL and the film sequences are now a pixilated mess, but it’s the best we’re ever going to have. On the other side of the spectrum, the un-RSC’d PAL material looks amazing with terrific color balance and contrast.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2398-5.jpg

Audio is presented in 2.0 mono. The NTSC episodes sound a tad bit muffled when held up to the original. Apparently the standards conversion process took a hit on the sound quality as well as the video.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2398-4.jpg

Features are slightly more technically oriented than usual. We start with the audio commentary featuring vets Barry Letts and Katy Manning with newcomer Richard Franklin. Katy’s not quite as annoying here as she’s been in the past.

Deleted and Extended Scenes have been recovered from an original studio session for Episode 1. Included is the original title sequence for the story (it was known as “Vampire From Space” back then).

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2398-7.jpg

Reverse Standards Conversion: The Axon Legacy is the next featurette and may bore some people to death. Jack Pizzy hosts tracing the evolution of standards conversion from the present way back to the early 50’s when Dr. Peter Axon developed the BBC’s first video recorder. If you have the stomach for it, it’s very fascinating albeit a brief. There is also some clips of how bad the 525 line conversions used to look.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2398-6.jpg


Katy Manning narrates another installment of Now and Then, this time centering on the Dungeness location where the exteriors were shot. It’s not as good as the ones seen on Dalek Invasion of Earth and Pyramids of Mars.

Finally Directing Who: Michael Ferguson continues John Kelly’s acclaimed interview series. Most of the featurette concerns Claws… with little involving his other stories.

Lord Dalek
11-09-2005, 02:23 AM
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2399-0.jpg


Story: ***** Video: ***** Sound ***** Extras: ***** Overall: *****


The story so far… the Doctor and Romana spend a holiday in Paris only to encounter bizarre rips in the fabric of space time. The perpetrators are the would-be mad scientist Kerensky (David “Dalek #2” Graham) and his employer the mysterious art forger Count Scarlioni (Julian “General Veers” Glover). Teamed up with a dopey but loveable private eye named Duggan (Tom Chadbon), the Doctor and Romana discover that Scarlioni is actually Scaroth, the last of the Jageroth, an alien shattered across time when his space ship blew up 400,000,000 years ago. Why does Scaroth want to steal the Mona Lisa, and how will it help him survive what should have been his demise?

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2399-1.jpg


City of Death is BRILLIANT. Based off a previous existing script entitled “The Gamble With Time” by David Fisher, Graham Williams and Douglas Adams (author of that most wholly remarkable book, The Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy) crafted one of the most crackling scripts to ever came out of the 70’s. The main strength of the story is Adams’s terrific dialogue like this exchange between the Doctor and Duggan after Duggan knocks out Kerensky.

Doctor: “If you do that one more time Duggan, I’m going to take some very serious measures.”
Duggan: “Yeah? Like what!?!”
Doctor: *Pauses* “I’m going to ask you not to.”

Oh and John Cleese is in it too.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2399-2.jpg


City of Death has always been a very successful story for the Beeb. It was the highest rated serial in the history of the original series and IIRC the highest selling VHS of all time on both sides of the Atlantic, so successful that it was released twice! A hugely popular story like this deserves a big DVD release and the DWRT did not disappoint. City Of Death is the first four part adventure to earn a 2-disc release (Curse Of Fenric doesn’t count as it was basically two single discs put together) The added space on disc 1 gives the video more space to breath producing a clean detailed image with no artifacts whatsoever. The Paris footage looks amazing in particular. The video is presented in 1.37:1 as usual.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2399-3.jpg




Audio is simple 2.0 mono. The show always sounded pretty good but the digital sound restoration evens everything out.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2399-4.jpg


Now to those insanely exhaustive extras:

A new AUDIO COMMENTARY featuring Director Michael Hayes, and actors Julian Glover and Tom Chadbon is provided here (Tom and Lalla denied to be involved). There’s a lot of great reporte in this trio leading to a fun and informative commentary.

PARIS IN THE SPRINGTIME is by far the best making of documentary dvd I’ve seen so far on a Doctor Who dvd. Written by Jonathan Morris in the style of Douglas Adams, and narrated by Toby “Prostetnic Vogon Jeltz” Longworth, this is a hilarious and at times melancholy look at the shining jewel in the middle of one of the worst seasons of Who ever made. It’s presented in 1.78:1 anamorphic widescreen.


http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2399-5.jpg


PARIS W12 is the title given to the second featurette, a 25 minute (condensed from four hours) selection of behind the scenes clips recovered from Shibaden tape. Its monochrome and time coded but if you get past that, it’s really fascinating.

PREHISTORIC LANDSCAPES and CHICKEN WRANGLER are two featurettes resurrecting Ian Scoones’s SFX work from the original 35mm film they were shot on. The latter is accompanied by that crazy theme from Grange Hill.

Finally we have EYE ON BLATCHFORD, another comedy bit reuniting the team behind the classic Oh, Mummy! in a takeoff of Panorama. Sardoth, the second to last of the Jagaroth, tries to get used to life in the titular hamlet only to get yelled at by his neighbors and run over by tourists. Gabriel “Sutekh” Wolfe has a great bit as a German psychiatrist.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2399-6.jpg



Oh and they’ve included the complete 1980 Dr. Who annual as a .pdf file.

How’s that for a two disc set!

IanC
11-09-2005, 03:17 PM
PREHISTORIC LANDSCAPES and CHICKEN WRANGLER are two featurettes resurrecting Ian Scoones’s SFX work from the original 35mm film they were shot on. The latter is accompanied by that crazy theme from Grange Hill.

That theme is apprently called Chicken Wrangler.

One thing ive always wondered, why are the menus like on the R1 releases?

Lord Dalek
11-09-2005, 06:05 PM
That theme is apprently called Chicken Wrangler.

One thing ive always wondered, what are the menus like on the R1 releases? http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2398-8.jpg


http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v92/lorddalek/E2398-9.jpg


As you can see they're almost exactly the same.

guinaevere
11-10-2005, 07:31 PM
Gosh what GREAT stuff!

I'm loving the RSC information. Being kinda loopy, I'm not completely understanding the process still, but when I'm off the meds, I'll give it another shot. =D